Are Existing LCIA Methods Related to Mineral and Metal Resources Relevant for an AESA Approach Applied to the Building Sector? Case Study on the Construction of New Buildings in France

Nada Bendahmane (1, 2, 3, 4, 5) , Natacha Gondran (2, 4, 5, 3) , Jacques Chevalier (1)

1 CSTB - Centre Scientifique et Technique du Bâtiment
2 Mines Saint-Étienne MSE - École des Mines de Saint-Étienne
3 EVS - Environnement, Ville, Société
4 FAYOL-ENSMSE - Institut Henri Fayol
5 FAYOL-ENSMSE - Département Génie de l’environnement pour les organisations

Considering the challenges that mineral and metallic resources represent for the building sector, there is a need to propose decision-support tools to building stakeholders. One of the possibilities could be to integrate an indicator of pressure on mineral resources in an absolute environmental sustainability assessment (AESA) approach, using life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) methods. This paper will analyze the existing LCIA indicators that can be used to represent the impact on mineral resources of new constructions, with a case study on new buildings in France in 2015. This analysis aims to find out whether the existing LCIA methods dealing with mineral and metallic resources issues are adapted to the specific stakes of the building sector in an AESA approach. The AESA approach considered is the one proposed by Bjørn and Hauschild. Several steps are detailed in this paper. Firstly, bibliographic research was carried out to identify existing LCIA methods related to the mineral resources. Secondly, selection criteria were defined in order to select those LCIA methods relevant for the building sector. Thirdly, the scope of the case study was defined and its inventory analysis was conducted using the Ecoinvent 3.5 database, selecting only the mineral and metallic input flows. Finally, the comparison between the inventory of mineral and metallic flows issued from the inventory analysis and the substances considered in the selected LCIA methods was effected. The results show that none of the existing LCIA methods are compatible with the aim of developing an LCIA indicator for mineral and metallic resources that is compatible with an AESA approach, in particular for the building sector.

Domaines: Environnement et Société

Nada Bendahmane, Natacha Gondran, Jacques Chevalier. Are Existing LCIA Methods Related to Mineral and Metal Resources Relevant for an AESA Approach Applied to the Building Sector? Case Study on the Construction of New Buildings in France. Sustainability, 2024, 16 (3), pp.1031. ⟨10.3390/su16031031⟩. ⟨hal-04417251⟩